Complete

Share

Favorite

Philip G. Cochran Memorial United Methodist Episcopal Church

Great Allegheny Passage

Commerce, Economy & Work Mining & Logging Religion

The church, erected in the 1920s in the Gothic Revival style, was inspired by Cochran’s European travels.

When we think about mining boomtowns in U.S. history, our minds travel westward to the gold, silver and copper towns that popped up—and sometimes disappeared just as quickly—in California, Idaho, Montana, Nevada and Colorado. But there were plenty of small towns in the northeast whose fortunes came and went over the course of two or three decades, though they did not fully disappear. [1] In Dawson, those fortunes depended on the rich bituminous coal seam running for miles below the ground of Southwestern Pennsylvania; enterprises like the Washington Coal and Coke Company mined the coal and then burned it to make coke—a potent fuel source needed to smelt iron, the base metal of steel. [2] The Washington Coal and Coke Company was founded in 1893 by several members of the Cochran family, whose history in the area's coke industry stretched back 50 years. The Cochrans lived in Dawson, and with their wealth they built several grand buildings, including the Philip G. Cochran Memorial United Methodist Church. Its limestone walls, steeply pitched roof, pointed arch windows and 100-foot-tall spire stand out in Dawson, where late Gothic Revival architecture is not the norm. [3]

Sarah B. Cochran (1857–1936) built the church to honor her late husband, Philip. Sarah Boyd Moore was a domestic servant in the home of James Cochran, Philip’s father. [4] Philip began working for his father's various coal, coke and banking enterprises in the 1870s and married Sarah in September 1879 despite her working-class background. [5] When Philip died in 1899 at age 50, Sarah oversaw the family’s business interests while she waited for their son, James Philip, to finish his schooling at the University of Pennsylvania. According to her obituary, "After his death she was elected to the boards of directors of the Washington Coal & Coke Company, Washington Run Railroad Company and the Star Supply Company …. She also succeeded her husband as a director of the First National Bank of Dawson, holding it at the time of her death.” [6] Upon turning 21, James Philip was to inherit two-thirds of his father’s estate, which was worth over a half million dollars. (To put this in perspective, imagine being handed a check for between $10 million and $15 million on your 21st birthday). [7] Sarah was devastated when, just two years after losing her husband, her son died of pneumonia. She departed for Europe and Asia and traveled abroad for a few years. [8]

When Sarah returned to Western Pennsylvania she began building Linden Hall, a 31-room Tudor Revival mansion, on her estate 3 miles from Dawson. [9] She often hosted gatherings and parties at this sumptuous residence, including meetings of Methodist Episcopal bishops and supporters of women’s suffrage. In 1915, 600 people gathered at Linden Hall to hear a presentation by Dr. Anna Howard Shaw, the president of the National American Women’s Suffrage Association, who told the assembled crowd: “The question of the ballot must be settled one way or the other this fall.” (It would not be settled for five more years. The 19th Amendment, granting women the right to vote, was ratified on Aug. 18, 1920). [10]

 

Sarah also supported causes by donating some of her great wealth. Although she took private train cars, wintered in Daytona and lived at Linden Hall in luxury, she also gave money to educational institutions, fraternities and the Methodist church. She made many gifts to Allegheny College, affiliated with the Methodist church, including one gift in 1906 for $50,000 that was double the amount industrialist Andrew Carnegie and John F. Eberthart, a Chicago real estate entrepreneur and school reformer, each gave at that time. [11]

The existing Philip G. Cochran Memorial United Methodist Church is actually the second that Sarah had built. Directly after her husband's death, on the same plot of land, she and her son erected a smaller church in Philip’s name. Influenced by the church architecture she saw in Europe during her travels, between 1922 and 1927 she had the church torn down and rebuilt in the Gothic Revival style at a cost of $325,000 (almost $5 million today). [12]

 

  • [1] National Register of Historic Places, Dawson Historic District , Dawson, Fayette County, Pennsylvania, National Register #97001252. Hereafter NRHP Dawson.
  • [2] Margaret M. Mulrooney, A Legacy of Coal: The Coal Company Towns of Southwestern Pennsylvania (Washington, DC: National Park Service, 1989), p. 35.
  • [3] National Register of Historic Places, Cochran, Philip G. Memorial United Methodist Church, Dawson, Fayette County, Pennsylvania, National Register #71995212.Hereafter NRHP Cochran; “High Victorian Gothic Style 1860–1890,”Pennsylvania Architectural Field Guide, Pennsylvania Historical & Museum Commission, accessed April 22, 2020, http://www.phmc.state.pa.us/portal/communities/architecture/styles/high-victorian-gothic.html.
  • [4] Kimberly Hess, "Sarah Cochran," National Women's History Museum, 2017, http://www.womenshistory.org/education-resources/biographies/sarah-cochran.
  • [5] “ Philip G. Cochran ” in The Progressive Men of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, ed. Col. Charles Blanchard (Chicago: A. W. Bowen & Company, 1900), 497–99.
  • [6] “Mrs. Sarah B. Cochran’s Death Closes Long Life Devoted to Human Needs,” Daily Courier (Connellsville, PA), October 28, 1936, front page.
  • [7] “The Grim Reaper,” Daily Courier (Connellsville, PA), March 8, 1901. The inflation estimate is from the Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI Inflation Calculator, which only goes back to 1913, so a larger range has been provided to adjust for the extra decade.
  • [8] Hess, “Sarah Cochran.” Note that the eight years of travel cited in the biography is incorrect or misleading; if Cochran traveled for eight years, she did return to the United States periodically. West Virginia newspapers report her chaperoning dances and hosting events in the 1906–08 time frame. For example, see: The Fairmont West Virginian., April 29, 1905, Chronicling America: Historic American Newspapers, Lib. of Congress, https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn86092557/1905-04-29/ed-1/seq-10/; The Fairmont West Virginian, February 15, 1906, Chronicling America: Historic American Newspapers, Lib. of Congress, https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn86092557/1906-02-15/ed-1/seq-5/; The Fairmont West Virginian, February 3, 1908, Chronicling America: Historic American Newspapers, Lib. of Congress, https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn86092557/1908-02-03/ed-1/seq-5/.
  • [9] National Register of Historic Places, Linden Hall Dawson, Fayette County, Pennsylvania, National Register #89001787.
  • [10] Kathryn L. Romanoff, “Stirring Rally for Suffrage in Fayette,” The Gazette Times (Pittsburgh, PA), June 30, 1915, page 7.
  • [11] "The Keystone State: The Latest Pennsylvania News Told in Short Order,” The Fulton County News (McConnellsburg, PA), June 13, 1906; "A Photograph of John F. Eberhart, the "Father of Chicago Lawn" and His Real Estate Office in the New Chicago Suburb,” c. 1870, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Eberhart_Real_Estate_Office.jpg.
  • [12] NRHP Cochran; NRHP Dawson. The inflation estimate is from the Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI Inflation Calculator.
References

Discover History on the Trail

Kenneth Reid and the Izaak Walton League of America

On March 12, 1931, a front-page headline in The Daily Courier of Connellsville, Pennsylvania, announced “Walton League Charter Closed With 61 Members:...

Trail: Great Allegheny Passage
State: PA
Nature & Environmental Management Politics, Policy & Justice
Connellsville Canteen

The Connellsville Canteen, which today is a café and museum, takes its name from the community-sponsored canteen that provided snacks and conversation...

Trail: Great Allegheny Passage
State: PA
Gender, Sexuality & Queerness Military & War Railroads Women's History
Layton Bridge

The Layton Bridge, constructed from 1893 to 1899 by Pencoyd Iron Works for the Washington Run Railroad, is an unusual Pratt pin-connected truss...

Trail: Great Allegheny Passage
State: PA
Industrialization and Deindustrialization Railroads
See All History

Discovering America: Reconnecting People and Places

The Great American Rail-Trail promises an all-new American experience. Through 12 states and the District of Columbia, the trail will directly serve nearly 50 million people within 50 miles of the route. Across the nation—and the world—only the limits of imagination will limit its use.

Learn More
traillink-logo

Help us to connect you with more trails!

TrailLink is a free service provided by Rails-to-Trails conservancy

(a non-profit) and we need your support!

Your donation will help us to continue connecting more people to trails around the country.
Become an RTC member and wear your FREE T-Shirt with pride. Help defend and expand trails nationwide.
Get a FREE Rail Trails Guidebook when you become a Member with Rails-to-Trails Conservancy.

Explore by City

Explore by City

Explore by Activity

Explore by Activity

Log in to your account to:

  • View trail paths on the map
  • Save trails to your account
  • Add trails, edit descriptions
  • Share photos
  • Add reviews

Log in with Google

Log in with Apple

OR

Register for free!

Join TrailLink (a non-profit) to view more than 40,000 miles of trail maps and more!

Register with Google

Register with Apple

OR

Your account has been deleted.