In front of the J. Wood Wilson House—now better known as Hostess House, a restaurant, event venue and gift shop—is a state historical marker for Samuel Plato (1882–1957). “African American architect and contractor,” the sign explains, “House here attributed to him.” [1] Plato built this mansion in 1912 for a Marion businessman and his wife, and it was one of his earliest—and certainly most grand—forays into Neo-Classical and Colonial Revival architecture. In 1912, Plato had lived in Marion for almost 10 years and was a decade into his career. After attending the State University in Louisville, Kentucky, at the turn of the 20th century, Plato learned architecture via a course from the International Correspondence School of Scranton, Pennsylvania. [2] He arrived in Marion in 1902 or 1903, attracted by the wealth amassing in the area as a result of Indiana’s natural gas boom.
Initially, Plato struggled to find work as an architectural draughtsman or contractor due to his race—being offered jobs only as a manual construction laborer or a carpenter. But when a contractor he was working for was dismissed for embezzling, his break finally came.
Plato was chosen as his boss’s replacement to finish the eight-room house. “When completed,” he told an audience in 1911, “the work was so well done that I secured four houses to build immediately, comprising in all 26 rooms.” [3]
Between 1903 and 1921, when he moved back to Louisville, Plato was the contractor on many buildings, several of which he designed. You can ride over to 917 South Adams St. to see the stunning Craftsman style home he designed and built in 1905, and then continue down South Adams to number 1415, the Platonian Apartments (1910). Or visit his 1913 commission, the First Baptist Church, at the corner of Fourth and Nebraska streets. [4]
Plato continued to face discrimination throughout his career. “How hard it was that a man should prepare himself in this life to make an honest living, and yet must be continually turned down on account of his color,” he said in an address to the National Negro Business League in 1911. [5]
Nevertheless, he would persevere. Plato would become a successful business owner in the early 20th century, credited with getting many Black laborers into building craft unions, which were notoriously segregated at the time.